May 08, 2023 - BY Admin

NHL playoffs: Leafs' top players disappeared when the team needed them most in Game 3

It was a must-win game, Alexander Kerfoot informed the traveling media group, a statement that seemed glaringly evident to anyone with even the slightest interest in the Toronto Maple Leafs. The team's greatest players, though, obviously didn't get the message.


After Sam Reinhart scored the overtime victory in Game 3, Toronto currently trails the Florida Panthers three games to none, an almost insurmountable deficit. This was perhaps the worst game of both Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner's seven-year tenures with the team.


The star-studded, top-heavy nucleus of the Maple Leafs is solely responsible for this defeat. While it's possible to forgive Morgan Rielly and William Nylander from this story, Marner, Matthews, and captain John Tavares were all out with a crucial season on the line and everything to play for. By anticipated goals at 5-on-5, Marner, Matthews, and Tavares were Toronto's worst players in regulation. However, you don't need the numbers to determine their impact—or lack thereof—on Sunday.


The Maple Leafs' star-studded, top-heavy core is wholly to blame for this loss. With a key season on the line and everything to play for, Marner, Matthews, and captain John Tavares were all out. However, it is easy to forgive Morgan Rielly and William Nylander from this incident. Marner, Matthews, and Tavares were Toronto's worst players in regulation based on projected goals at 5-on-5. You don't necessarily need to know the stats to judge if they had an influence on Sunday or not.


The sobering truth that, barring one of the statistically impossible comebacks in the history of North American men's sports, the series is lost, in embarrassing manner, has overwhelmed all the hope and optimism that this year would be different for the Maple Leafs. Furthermore, you cannot even claim that the Maple Leafs' players were simply outplayed because they failed to appear.


A first-round departure would be viewed as unacceptable, and heads would roll, so Toronto put all of its chips in. A second-round exit serves no purpose if the outcome is the same in reality.


With the intention of bolstering a highly talented core group that couldn't get past the hump, Ryan O'Reilly, Noel Acciari, Sam Lafferty (who scored the game's first goal and is one of the few players exempt from criticism in this one), Luke Schenn, and Jake McCabe joined the Maple Leafs at the trade deadline. Eight days after assisting the Maple Leafs in putting out their devil, the team is once more at the starting line, but this time without an explanation or any justifications.


By some stroke of luck, the Maple Leafs were given a perfect matchup and went into the game as the overwhelming favorite. Instead, they let their greatest players go during the most important games of their careers and relied on the supporting cast to fill the void. The Maple Leafs had everything go their way, but the team's star players missed a chance to shine in the most important season of their professional careers. Picking through the trash is a disgusting but fitting conclusion.